Does Pennsylvania Cap Damages in Car Accident Claims?
Not when a private driver causes the crash. The Pennsylvania Constitution bars the General Assembly from limiting what an injured person can recover. Claims against government agencies are different: damages are capped at $250,000 per person and $1,000,000 per crash when a Commonwealth agency is responsible, and at $500,000 per crash when a local agency is responsible. A limited tort election and the at-fault driver’s policy limits can also affect what may be recovered.
No Cap on Damages Against a Private At-Fault Driver
When a crash is caused by a private driver, Pennsylvania law does not cap what an injured person can recover. The protection comes from the Pennsylvania Constitution. Article III, Section 18 states that, other than through workers’ compensation laws, the General Assembly may not “limit the amount to be recovered for injuries resulting in death, or for injuries to persons or property.”
That means a claim against a private at-fault driver is not cut off at a set dollar figure by statute. What the claim may be worth depends on the injuries, the evidence and the losses that can be proven, including medical expenses, lost earnings and pain and suffering.
Two things can still limit what an injured person actually recovers, even without a statutory cap:
| Limit | What it is | Where it’s covered |
|---|---|---|
| A limited tort election | A choice on the injured person’s own policy that may bar recovery of pain and suffering, unless an exception applies | The limited tort section, below |
| The at-fault driver’s insurance | The amount of coverage available to pay the claim | The policy limits section, below |
Different rules apply when the at-fault party is a government agency, as the next two sections explain. The lawyers at Schmidt Kramer Injury Lawyers can review who caused the crash and which rules may apply, so the claim is built around the full value of the loss.
Claims Against the Commonwealth
When a crash involves a Commonwealth agency, or one of its employees acting within the scope of employment, a different set of rules applies. Pennsylvania generally protects the Commonwealth from lawsuits through sovereign immunity. The General Assembly has waived that protection in specific cases, including the operation of any motor vehicle in the possession or control of a Commonwealth party. A claim may also be brought for some dangerous conditions on highways under a Commonwealth agency’s jurisdiction.
Where the waiver applies, the law limits both the amount and the kinds of damages that can be recovered:
| Rule | Commonwealth claims |
|---|---|
| Cap per injured person | $250,000 |
| Cap for all claims from the same crash | $1,000,000 |
| Damages recoverable | Past and future lost earnings and earning capacity; pain and suffering; medical and dental expenses; loss of consortium; property losses |
| Exception | Property losses cannot be recovered in claims based on potholes, sinkholes and similar highway conditions |
The cap applies even when a jury finds the losses are far higher. In a case decided on October 1, 2026, a pedestrian in a crosswalk was struck by a SEPTA bus and underwent a partial amputation of one foot. The parties agreed to a $7 million verdict, and the verdict was reduced to $250,000 under the cap. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court upheld the cap and stated that “it is for the legislature to provide for remedies, including any limitations on the type or amount of the remedies.”
When a cap may limit what the government party pays, other sources of recovery can become more important. Our lawyers can review whether another driver, a private company or the injured person’s own coverage may also be responsible, so that the claim isn’t limited to one capped source.
Claims Against Local Agencies
Local government has its own immunity rules. Pennsylvania law defines a local agency as a government unit other than the Commonwealth government. A local agency is generally immune from damages; however, there may be exceptions. One is the operation of any motor vehicle in the possession or control of the local agency. Others may include dangerous conditions of trees, traffic signs, lights or other traffic controls, and of streets owned by the local agency and their sidewalks. These require proof that the condition created a reasonably foreseeable risk of the kind of injury that occurred, and that the agency had notice in time to protect against it.
Where an exception applies, local agency claims carry a higher cap than Commonwealth claims but tighter limits on pain and suffering:
| Rule | Commonwealth claims | Local agency claims |
|---|---|---|
| Cap | $250,000 per injured person; $1,000,000 for all claims from the same crash | $500,000 for all claims from the same crash |
| Pain and suffering | Recoverable | Recoverable only for death, or for permanent loss of a bodily function, permanent disfigurement or permanent dismemberment where medical and dental expenses exceed $1,500 |
| Other damages recoverable | Lost earnings and earning capacity; medical and dental expenses; loss of consortium; property losses | Lost earnings and earning capacity; medical and dental expenses; loss of consortium; loss of support; property losses |
| Insurance benefits | No deduction provision in the cap statute | Benefits the injured person receives or is entitled to receive under insurance other than life insurance are deducted from the damages |
The $500,000 cap is shared among everyone with a claim from the same crash. In a crash with several injured people, each person’s share may be smaller than the cap suggests. The deduction for insurance benefits can also reduce the amount recovered, because benefits the injured person receives, or is entitled to receive, for losses covered by the claim are subtracted.
These rules make the details of a local agency claim especially important. Our lawyers can review whether an exception to immunity applies, whether the injury may meet the permanent-injury requirement for pain and suffering, and how insurance benefits may affect the final recovery.
Limited Tort, a Limit That Isn’t a Cap
Limited tort doesn’t set a dollar figure, but it can still affect what a person hurt in a Pennsylvania crash may recover. It is a choice made on the injured person’s own auto policy, and it can limit the right to recover for pain and suffering.
Under Pennsylvania law, a person bound by the limited tort election remains eligible to seek compensation for economic loss caused by another driver’s fault. The notice Pennsylvania requires on auto insurance forms states that limited tort policyholders “may seek recovery for all medical and other out-of-pocket expenses, but not for pain and suffering or other nonmonetary damages unless the injuries suffered fall within the definition of ‘serious injury.’”
| Full tort | Limited tort | |
|---|---|---|
| Medical and other out-of-pocket expenses | May be recovered | May be recovered |
| Pain and suffering | May be recovered | Only if the injury is a “serious injury,” or an exception applies |
Pennsylvania law defines a serious injury as a personal injury resulting in death, serious impairment of body function or permanent serious disfigurement. The law also lists exceptions in which a limited tort policyholder keeps full tort rights, including when the at-fault driver:
- Is convicted of, or accepts Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition (ARD) for, driving under the influence in that crash
- Was operating a vehicle registered in another state
- Had not maintained the financial responsibility the law requires
Another exception applies when the injured person was an occupant of a vehicle other than a private passenger vehicle. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has also held that limited tort restrictions do not apply to a pedestrian struck by a vehicle.
A limited tort election can make the difference between a claim that includes pain and suffering and one that doesn’t.
From Scott Cooper
Limited tort does not automatically eliminate a Pennsylvania accident victim’s claim for pain and suffering. We review the insurance policies and facts of the crash for exceptions to limited tort, and we examine the medical evidence and the real-world effect of the injuries — how long they last, the treatment required, whether they are permanent, and how they impair work and everyday activities — to determine whether the serious-injury threshold can be met.
— Scott B. Cooper, Partner, Schmidt Kramer Injury Lawyers
These pages cover each question in more detail: limited tort vs. full tort, the serious injury threshold and exceptions to limited tort.
Policy Limits, a Practical Limit
Even when no statute caps the damages, the at-fault driver’s insurance often decides how much money is actually available. Pennsylvania requires only modest liability coverage:
| Coverage | Pennsylvania minimum |
|---|---|
| Injury to one person in one accident | $15,000 |
| Injury to two or more people in one accident | $30,000 |
| Damage to the property of others in one accident | $5,000 |
A serious injury may cost far more than a minimum policy pays. When the at-fault driver’s coverage runs out, other sources may help close the gap. One of them is underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage on the injured person’s own policy. Pennsylvania law requires insurers to offer UIM coverage with every auto liability policy, but buying it is optional. A person hurt by a driver whose liability limits are insufficient to pay the losses may be eligible to recover under UIM coverage, if that coverage was purchased.
Stacking may increase that coverage. When more than one vehicle is insured under one or more policies with UIM coverage, Pennsylvania law applies the UIM limit separately to each vehicle, so the limits may be combined, or “stacked,” unless the named insured signed a written waiver of stacking.
From Scott Cooper
When an accident victim’s losses exceed the at-fault driver’s insurance coverage in Pennsylvania, the most important avenues to investigate are:
- UIM coverage under the victim’s own policy.
- Stacked UIM coverage under multiple applicable policies.
- Personal liability of the at-fault driver.
- Additional defendants who may share legal responsibility.
- Umbrella and commercial excess insurance.
- Workers’ compensation and other available insurance benefits.
One important recommendation: Before signing a settlement agreement or release with the at-fault driver’s insurance company, have a Pennsylvania personal injury attorney review all potentially applicable insurance policies. This can prevent the accidental loss of rights to additional compensation.
— Scott B. Cooper, Partner, Schmidt Kramer Injury Lawyers
The pages on insurance policy limits and uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage explain these options in more detail.
An Earlier Deadline for Government Claims
Pennsylvania’s general deadline to file a lawsuit for injuries caused by negligence is two years. When the claim is against a government unit, there is an earlier step. Written notice of the claim must be filed within six months of the date of the injury.
The notice must be filed with the government unit responsible. If the claim is against a Commonwealth agency, it must also be filed with the Office of Attorney General. The statement must be in writing, signed by or on behalf of the person with the claim, and must include:
- The name and residence address of the person with the claim
- The name and residence address of the person injured
- The date and hour of the accident
- The approximate location where the accident occurred
- The name and residence or office address of any attending physician
If the notice isn’t filed on time, a lawsuit filed more than six months after the injury will be dismissed and the claim barred, unless a court finds a reasonable excuse for the late notice. For claims against a government unit other than the Commonwealth government, the law also provides these protections:
| Rule | What it means |
|---|---|
| Incapacity | Time when the injured person is unable to give notice because of the injury is not counted, up to 90 days |
| Death | If the injuries result in death, the six months begins on the date of death |
| Notice already given | Late notice is not a bar if the government unit had actual or constructive notice of the incident or condition that led to the claim |
Six months can pass quickly while someone is recovering from a serious injury. Our lawyers can identify early whether a government vehicle, road or agency may be involved, and prepare the notice within the deadline. The Pennsylvania car accident statute of limitations page covers the two-year deadline and other time limits in more detail.
When the Policy Limit Isn’t the Whole Story
The limits above can look final on paper. Scott Cooper, a partner at Schmidt Kramer Injury Lawyers, describes a Pennsylvania claim where the at-fault driver’s coverage raised that concern:
From Scott Cooper
In one Pennsylvania matter, the available liability insurance presented a real concern that the coverage might not be enough to compensate the injured person fully. Rather than treating the stated policy limit as the end of the case, the firm investigated other potential sources of recovery. That included examining whether additional or umbrella coverage existed, reviewing the injured person’s own uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage and possible stacking, and investigating whether assets or other responsible parties could provide another avenue of recovery.
The important lesson is that the number on the at-fault driver’s declarations page is not necessarily the amount an injured person ultimately has available. Before accepting a policy-limits settlement or signing a release, every potentially applicable policy and source of recovery should be investigated.
— Scott B. Cooper, Partner, Schmidt Kramer Injury Lawyers
How Schmidt Kramer Can Help
Caps, notice rules and insurance limits can decide how much a claim may be worth before negotiations begin. Our lawyers work to identify those limits early, so they don’t decide the outcome by default.
After a Pennsylvania crash, our lawyers can:
- Identify who may be responsible, including private drivers, businesses and any government unit
- Determine which rules may apply, including the Commonwealth and local agency caps and the limits on the kinds of damages that can be recovered
- Meet the six-month notice requirement when a government vehicle, road or agency may be involved
- Review the injured person’s own policy, including a limited tort election and any underinsured motorist coverage
- Pursue every available source of payment, rather than a single capped source
Questions about caps and limits can arise in any crash in South Central Pennsylvania. Schmidt Kramer Injury Lawyers is based in Harrisburg and serves Harrisburg and Dauphin County, along with Carlisle, Hanover, Lancaster and the greater South Central Pennsylvania region. Our Harrisburg car accident lawyers also represent people hurt in Carlisle car crashes, Hanover car accidents and Lancaster car accidents. Request a free case review to learn which limits may apply to your claim and how our lawyers can help.